Strength Training vs HIIT: Different Workouts, Different Benefits (Why You Need Both)

Training ADHD in a World of Fitness Hype

The fitness industry has done you wrong—not because available information is bad, but because everyone’s selling you their “one magic pill” solution. Big chains, influencers, and bootcamp classes need you to believe their single modality fixes everything. That’s marketing, not science.

After years of coaching real athletes in the trenches, I can offer this truth: there is no one answer to optimal fitness. It’s about the right dose of different training modalities.

Today we’ll break down the critical differences between strength training and metabolic conditioning (often oversimplified as “HIIT” or Metcons) and why timing them intelligently—not mashing them together—is key to performing your best.

The Problem: Everything Becomes a Sweaty Mess

Ever find yourself racing through a workout, drenched in sweat, wondering if you’re doing it right? You’re not alone.

In today’s fitness culture, there’s massive hype around high-intensity interval training, “metabolic” bootcamps, and sweat-soaked circuits. Meanwhile, traditional strength training gets pushed aside—or worse, gets mashed together with conditioning until everything becomes a painful mish-mash without any proper direction towards adaptation.

Many active adults (especially those 30+) who still love skiing, biking, and mountain adventures struggle to balance these approaches. Should you lift heavy with long rests, or do rapid-fire circuits? Can resting longer possibly benefit endurance athletes?

The truth: strength training and HIIT are distinct training methods with unique stimuli and adaptations. Understanding their differences—and how they complement each other—is key to training smart, staying healthy, and performing your best.

What Exactly Is Strength Training?

Strength training means exercises with heavy resistance performed specifically to increase maximal force production. According to the NSCA, true strength training focuses on developing neuromuscular adaptations like improved motor unit recruitment, synchronization, and firing rate.

Classic strength workouts involve high intensity (heavy loads) for low-to-moderate reps with adequate rest between sets. You might do 5 heavy squats, then rest 2-3 minutes before the next set. That rest isn’t laziness—it’s when your body replenishes energy stores and recovers the neural drive required for maximal effort.

Key point for endurance athletes: Strength training is primarily neurological adaptation. Higher reps with lighter loads or bodyweight won’t yield the strength adaptations you’re looking for—that’s a different stimulus entirely.

What Proper Strength Training Feels Like

During a strength session, your heart rate will spike briefly on heavy lifts, but you shouldn’t be breathless between sets. If you’re gasping and your goal is strength, you need longer rest periods.

One of the biggest mistakes people make is turning strength workouts into conditioning by rushing rest periods. The result? Your muscles and nervous system never fully recover, so you lift lighter with poor form or can’t more very much weight —essentially doing accidental metabolic training that shortchanges strength gains.

You don’t necessarily have to lift like a powerlifter, but it can help to understand their approach and why: they take 3-5+ minutes between heavy sets because those long rests let the fastest, strongest muscle fibers and central nervous system recover fully for maximal force production.

Bottom line: Strength training prioritizes intensity of effort over density of work. Volume and rep schemes should vary based on your experience and skill level. But the effort needs to be focused on moving heavier weights with adequate rest.

Lastly, you don’t need to be doing heavy strength splits all year. Like many training modalities, it should undulate throughout the year. You can make adjustments based on your fitness focuses. That being said, you should have 1-2 focused programs per year where your priority should be adding strength.

Energy Systems and Adaptations

Strength training primarily uses the anaerobic alactic system (ATP-PCr), providing explosive energy for 10-15 seconds max. After that, your aerobic system quietly works during rest periods to clear fatigue and refill energy stores.

Train consistently with proper strength protocols and your body adapts through:

Increased Neuromuscular Strength: Your brain gets better at recruiting more muscle fibers and firing them in sync. Early strength gains come from improved neural drive before muscles even grow.

Muscle Hypertrophy: With adequate volume and nutrition, strength training increases muscle cross-sectional area. Bigger muscles produce more force and raise metabolic rate. However, hypertrophy specific programming is often quite different than strength specific. This will depend on your experience in the gym, genetic factors, age, and more.

Stronger Bones and Connective Tissue: Heavy loading stimulates bone density and strengthens tendons and ligaments—crucial “armor” against injury whether you’re lifting luggage or carving down a mountain.

Sport Performance Benefits: Being stronger makes everything easier. Build a stronger squat and each pedal stroke or ski turn takes a smaller percentage of your maximum force. Strength is also the foundation of power (power = strength × speed).

Important limitation: Strength training alone won’t improve cardiovascular endurance much—and it’s not supposed to. You’ll get strong and muscular but not well-conditioned for long activities. Strength endurance is certainly a trainable quality, but it’s not as simple as high reps = strength endurance.

What Is HIIT (Metabolic Conditioning)?

High-Intensity Interval Training involves repeated bouts of very intense effort interspersed with variable rest periods. Examples include track sprints, burpee circuits, kettlebell intervals, or rowing sprints—typically 20-90 seconds of near-maximal work followed by recovery periods.

If you can keep going hard with no rest, you’re not at true HIIT intensity. By design, HIIT is anaerobic (lactic) during work intervals and aerobic during recovery as your heart rate drops.

What HIIT/Metabolic Training Sessions Feel Like

During work intervals, your heart rate should skyrocket, you’ll experience heavy breathing, and your muscles will burn. Appropriate metabolic training sessions can certainly have you questioning your life decisions.

Metabolic Training has to be a concentrated effort —instead of jogging 30 minutes at a moderate pace, you might do 10 one-minute sprints with breaks to thoroughly exhaust your capacity. Both train your aerobic system, but HIIT also pushes you into the anaerobic red zone repeatedly. This isn’t just intentional suffering – It trains your body to manage stress all the way down to a cellular level.

Metabolic Training Adaptations

Improved Aerobic Capacity: Some studies have suggested that metabolic training can increase VO₂ max as much as traditional endurance training in a fraction of the time. The famous McMaster University study showed 20 minutes of interval training produced similar aerobic improvements as 90-120 minutes of steady cycling. However, I would caution against replacing endurance training with HIIT training. Those studies suggested that you work at 120% of your maximum output for short bursts, which is exceptionally difficult. Instead, view metabolic conditioning as training your body to handle stress more efficiently and recovery faster between hard efforts even in action.

Greater Anaerobic Capacity: Your muscles get better at tolerating and clearing metabolites, so you can sustain high efforts longer and recover faster between bursts—crucial for stop-and-go sports or steep climbs.

Metabolic Health: HIIT improves insulin sensitivity, blood pressure, and cardiovascular markers. It also elevates post-exercise metabolic rate (the “afterburn” effect) for hours after training. It has recently been suggested that it can improve longevity and cognitive health long term as well.

Fat Loss: HIIT burns more calories per minute than lower-intensity exercise and is more muscle-sparing than excessive steady cardio.

Important limitation: While HIIT offers excellent conditioning benefits, those 20-minute metcons and bootcamp classes can’t prepare you for long days in the mountains, on the bike, or trail running. That requires a different approach to aerobic development—but that’s a topic for another article.

Why You Need Both (Not a Mish-Mash)

Strength training and HIIT shouldn’t be competing—they’re complementary. One builds your physical chassis (muscles, bones, strength), the other tunes your engine (cardiovascular capacity and efficiency).

Recent research highlighted by Joel Jamieson: As little as 30 minutes of strength training per week was associated with 10-20% lower all-cause mortality. But combining strength with aerobic training? About 40% lower risk—roughly double the benefit.

The “Mish-Mash” Trap

A common mistake in bootcamp classes, Crossfit, Hyrox, and among inexperienced trainees is mixing strength and HIIT incorrectly—moderately heavy weights lifted fast with insufficient rest interspersed with fatigued interval efforts, day after day.

You might think you’re getting the best of both worlds, but you’re often getting the best of neither:

• Strength gains require high intensity (heavy load) and adequate recovery
• HIIT gains require high intensity (heart rate) and adequate recovery between intervals

Perpetual circuits lead to chronic fatigue, poor movement quality, plateaued strength (never lifting truly heavy or fresh), and plateaued conditioning (never pushing max effort or allowing adaptation).

Do we use interval training from time to time? Absolutely. But we provide very specific parameters, recognize that the stress accumulation is HIGH, and the adaptations happen quickly. So the programs are short and intentional. And they are all out, not sloppy.

Smart Integration

Organize your week so some sessions target strength with proper intensity and rest, others focus on conditioning. Many experts now follow a high/low/high/low model – IE One high output day followed by a low one. This requires a lot of discipline, whether it’s in the gym or on the trails.

Other examples can include:

Option 1: Lift heavy first, then finish with a brief metabolic “finisher” (5-10 minutes max) once strength work is complete.

Option 2: Separate days entirely—Monday/Wednesday/Friday strength, Tuesday/Saturday conditioning, with low-intensity recovery work filling gaps.

The key: These all depend on your fitness level, training background, and what you need to address presently. Energy is finite. You can’t maximize everything simultaneously. Prioritize one modality while maintaining the others based on your current goals and season.

Signs You’re Doing It Right

When balanced properly, you’ll notice:

• Strength progressing or maintaining while cardio improves
• Energy for heavy lifts because you’re not exhausted from yesterday’s HIIT
• Ability to push harder during conditioning because legs aren’t destroyed from squats earlier
• Reduced injury risk and overtraining
• Faster recovery time between workouts or even hard consecutive efforts (Think cycling ascents or backcountry skiing transitions)

The Bottom Line

In a fitness landscape full of quick-fix marketing, don’t fall for the “one solution” trap. Both strength training and HIIT are powerful—but in different ways.

Embrace your heavy lifting days: Enjoy the grind of getting stronger and hitting new PRs.

Embrace your HIIT days: Relish the sweat and endorphin rush knowing you’re pushing aerobic capacity. Don’t dog it or finish up with a bunch of slow cardio after. Send it and call it.

Just don’t confuse the two. Give each its own space to shine, and you’ll build what every athlete desires: a body prepared for anything.

As research consistently shows, the greatest rewards come from mixing training styles intelligently. It’s not strength versus conditioning—it’s both working together to create muscle with hustle, strength with endurance, and a body built for long-term performance.

---

Want to learn how to structure strength and conditioning for your specific goals? Our coaches at Revo Training Center specialize in building programs that work with your outdoor adventures, not against them.

At Revo, we don’t just run workouts — we coach humans.

If you’re ready to train with intention, move better, and build real-world strength, we’d love to work with you.

Here’s how we can help:

👉 Try RevoFit – Your first 10 days are free. No pressure, just smart training.
👉 Get a Free Strategy Session – We’ll map out a custom training plan based on your goals and lifestyle.
👉 Learn More About Semi-Private Coaching – For outdoor athletes and everyday humans who want expert guidance and accountability.

🔗 Explore Membership Options
🔗 Book a Free Strategy Session